President's Message
“Live in D.C. long enough and you’ll learn that most public debate takes the form of “either-or” arguments. You know what I mean: “either we do things this way, or … [here you can fill in your own catastrophe].” Recently, around town, I’ve heard actual people make the following statements:
• “Either we reform the endangered species act or we’re dooming tens of thousands of species to extinction.”
• “Either we teach more science in elementary school, or kids will grow up to be knee-jerk opponents of economic progress.”
• “Either we adopt wind power, a renewable source of energy, or our kids will grow up fighting wars in the Middle East to protect our access to oil.”
• “Either we severely limit use of wind power, or we’ll kill so many bats our ecology will be disrupted.”
There’s no doubt these folks sincerely believed what they were saying. But framing an argument this way makes it almost impossible to come up with good decisions – for the simple reason that no issue is ever as simple as you want it to be.
That’s why AFF casts its net widely before we come to conclusions about any public issue.
Our Project Learning Tree team consults regularly with other leaders in the environmental education field – from universities, other non-profits, and teachers on the front lines. AFF staffers are deeply involved in national organizations: North American Association for Environmental Education, National Science Teachers Association, National Alliance of Black School Educators, and many others. Based on what we learn, AFF’s Project LearningTree Operating Committee adopts policies that reflect their best, informed judgment of how state and Federal policies can advance PLT’s mission of preparing young people to make sound environmental choices.
Likewise, on forestry-related issues, we work through the American Tree Farm System National Operating Committee, and its National Public Affairs Committee. Our first step, though, is to consult with a variety of other interest groups. AFF, for example, helps lead the National Council on Private Forests – a D.C. based group made up of the Society of American Foresters, the National Association of State Foresters, National Association of Conservation Districts, and Forest Landowners.
We’re also helping to organize a broad-based national coalition of environmental and conservation groups that share our concerns about the future of family forest lands.
Consultation takes time. We don’t always hear what we wanted, or what we expected – so we learn as we listen, whether it’s to teachers in classrooms or family forest owners in the field. Overall, it’s a complicated, sometimes messy process. Often, we defy the conventional wisdom and adopt positions that can’t easily be boiled down to a one-sentence sound-bite. But, by the time we’re done, we’re satisfied that we’ve come to a decision that will help address real issues that matter to the people and communities we serve — 500,000 educators and 51,000 Tree Farmers. And, by reaching out right from the beginning, we’ve assembled an army of allies who can help us make it happen.

Laurence Wiseman, President
>> return to top |